Objective To investigate the effect of homograft of marrow mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) seeded onto poly-L-lactic acid (PLLA)/gelatin on repair of articular cartilage defects. Methods The MSCs derived from36 Qingzilan rabbits, aging 4 to 6 months and weighed 2.5-3.5 kg were cultured in vitroand seeded onto PLLA/gelatin. The MSCs/ PLLA/gelatin composite was cultured and transplanted into full thickness defects on intercondylar fossa. Thirty-six healthy Qingzilan rabbits were made models of cartilage defects in the intercondylar fossa. These rabbits were divided into 3 groups according to the repair materials with 12 in each group: group A, MSCs and PLLA/gelatin complex(MSCs/ PLLA/gelatin); group B, only PLLA/gelatin; and group C, nothing. At 4,8 and 12 weeks after operation, the gross, histological and immunohistochemical observations were made, and grading scales were evaluated. Results At 12 weeks after transplantation, defect was repaired and the structures of the cartilage surface and normal cartilage was in integrity. The defects in group A were repaired by the hylinelike tissue and defects in groups B and C were repaired by the fibrous tissues. Immunohistochemical staining showed that cells in the zones of repaired tissues were larger in size, arranged columnedly, riched in collagen Ⅱ matrix and integrated satisfactorily with native adjacent cartilages and subchondral bones in group A at 12 weeks postoperatively. In gross score, group A(2.75±0.89) was significantly better than group B (4.88±1.25) and group C (7.38±1.18) 12 weeks afteroperation, showing significant differences (P＜0.05); in histological score, group A (3.88±1.36) was better than group B (8.38±1.06) and group C (13.13±1.96), and group B was better than group C, showing significant differences (P＜0.05). Conclusion Transplantation of mesenchymal stem cells seeded onto PLLA/gelatin is a promising way for the treatment of cartilage defects.
Objective To explore the relationship of the limited resource of the autologous bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) in articularcavity to the treatment results of full-thickness articular cartilage defect, and to investigate whether the extrogenous sodium hyaluronate(SH) promotes the migration of MSCs cultured in vitro tothe articular defect in vivo. Methods Sixty-six Japan rabbits were made the model of the full-thickness articular cartilage defect (5 mm width and 4 mm depth).The autologous MSCs were extracted from the rabbit femur, cultured in vitro, labeledby Brdu, and injected into the injured articular cavity with or without SH. Theexperiment was divided into 4 groups; group A (MSCs and SH, n=15); group B (MSCs, n=15); group C (SH, n=18); and group D (non-treatment, n=18). The morphologic observation was made by HE staining, Mallory staining and immunohistochemical staining after 5 weeks, 8 weeks and 12 weeks of operation. Results There were significant differences in the thickness of repairing tissue between group A and group B(Plt;0.01); but there were no significant differences between group A and group C, and between group B and group D(P＞0.05). Thehistological observation showed that the main repairing tissue was fibrocartilage in group A and fiber tissue in group B. Conclusion MSCs cultured in vitro and injected into the articular cavity can not improve the treatment results of the articular cartilage defect. Extrogenous SH has effect on repairing cartilage defect. The extrogenous SH has no effect on the chemotaxis of the MSCs, and on the collection of MSCs into the joint defect.
Objective To explore the methods of repairing cartilagedefects and to introduce the clinical experience with the autologous osteochondral transplantation. Methods Twenty-five patients with chondral and osteochondral defects of the weight-bearing surfaces were treated by the autologous osteochondral transplantation for the repair of the chondral and osteochondral defects of the unweightbearing surfaces under arthroscope. According to the shape of the defects, the different dimensions of the osteochondral autograft were selected. All the patients began the training of the continuous passive motion after operation. Six weeks after operation, the patients began to walk in the weightbearing habitus. However, in the control group, another 25 patients were retrospectively analyzed, who had chondral and osteochondral defects of the weight-bearing surfaces but were treated only by the cleaning and drilling procedures. The scores evaluated bythe Brittberg-Peterson scoring scale of the 2 group were 98.65±9.87 and 96.98±8.94 respectively. Results The follow-upfor 3-24 months after operation revealed that the treated knee joint had a goodmotion extent. The pain was obviously alleviated. Based on the longitudinal study with the three-dimensional spoiled magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), the signal intensity of the repaired tissues approached to the normal condition. The scores evaluated by the Brittberg-Peterson scoring scale were almost zero 3 monthsafter operation in the experimental group, and the scores were 58.48±6.98 inthe control group. There were significant differences between the experimental group and the control group(P＜0.01). Conclusion Autologous osteochondral transplanation under arthroscope is a good curative method for the cartilage defects, with advantages of minimal invasiveness and avoidanceofrejections resulting from allografts. However, its long-term effect needs to befurther studied. The conventional therapies including cleaning and drilling are useful in alleviating the symptoms.
Objective To investigate the curative effects of homograft of the mesenchymal stem cells(MSCs) compbined with the medical collagen membrane of the guided tissue regeneration(MCMG) on the full thickness defects of the articular cartilage. Methods MSCs derived from New Zealand rabbits aged 3-4 months weighing 2.1-3.4 kg were cultured in vitro with a density of 5.5×108/ml and seeded onto MCMG. The MSC/MCMG complex was cultured for 48 h and transplanted into the fullthickness defects on the inboardcondyle and trochlea. Twenty-seven healthy New Zealand rabbits were randomly divided into 3 groups of 9rabbits in each. The cartilage defects in the inboard condyle and trochlea werefilled with the auto bone marrow MSCs and MCMG complex (MSCs/ MCMG) in Group A (Management A), with only MCMG in Group B (Management B)and with nothing in Group C (Management C). Three rabbits were killed at 4, 8 and 12 weeks after operation in each group, and the reparative tissue samples evaluated grossly,histologically and immunohistochemically were graded according tothe gross and histological scale. Results Four weeks after transplantation, the cartilage and subchondralbone were regenerated in Group A;for 12 weeks, the regenerated cartilage gradually thicked; 12 week after transplantation, the defect was repaired and the structures of the carticular surface and subchondral bone was in integrity.The defects in Group A were repaired by the hylinelike tissue and the defects in Groups B and C were repaired by the fibrous tissues. Glycosaminoglycan and type Ⅱcollagen in Groups A,B and C were reduced gradually.The statistical analysis on the gross at 12 weeks and the histologicalgradings at 4 weeks,8 weeks and 12 weeks showed that the inboardcondylar repairhad no significant difference compared with the rochlearepair(Pgt;0.05).Management A was significantly better than Managements B and C (Plt;0.05), and Management B was better than Management C(Plt;0.05). Conclusion Transplantation of the MSCs combined with MCMG on the full thickness defects of the articular cartilage is a promising approach to the the treatment of cartilage defects. MCMG can satisfy the demands of the scaffold for the tissue-engineered cartilage.
Objective To investigate the effectiveness of mosaicplasty in repair of large-sized osteochondral compound defects and the integrity of transplanted tissue with recipient sites so as to lay a foundation for clinical application. Methods Twenty-four adult goats were divided into 3 groups randomly. The diameters of defect were 6 mm for the medium-sized defects and 9 mm for the large-sized defects, which were created by a trepan. All of the defects were repaired with osteochondral plugs in diameters of 2 mm(the mediumsized defects) or 3 mm(the large-sized defects). The osteochondral plugs were harvested around the intercondylar fossa or intertrochlea groove, and pressed into the recipient sites by specialized instruments in a mosaic mode. No internal fixation was needed and the animal wereallowed to move freely after operation. From 4 to 24 weeks postoperatively, thespecimens were observed in gross and under electromicroscopy. X-ray detection and glycosaminoglycan(GAG) analysis were also performed to testify the healing processand the integrity of the cartilage and subchondral bone. Results The transplanted subchondral bone was integrated firmly with each other or with recipient sites in both mosaicplasty groups. But 24 weeks postoperatively, transplanted cartilage was not integrate with each other apparently. Obvious cleavage between cartilage plugs could be seen. But in the largesized defect groups, some of the osteochondral plugs were relapsed into the defects leaving the recipient sites some steps, leading to some degree of abrasion in the opposing articular cartilage. There was no significant difference in the GAG content between the transplanted cartilage and normal cartilage. X-ray analysis also demonstrated the healing process between the subchondral bone. Conclusion Mosaicplasty can repair the medium or small-sized osteochondral defects efficiently.
Objective To investigate the clinical application of periosteal autograft in repair of cartilage defect caused by osteoarthritis of knee. Methods From 1996 to 1999, 36 knees of cartilage defect of knee joint in 28 cases were treated. In the operation, the cracked degenerative cartilage was removed before free periosteum from tibia was transplanted to repair the defect, and the meniscuses in 8 knees of the 36 knees were reconstructed. After operation, early continuous passive movement was adopted for 4 weeks, and 8 knees with reconstruction ofthe meniscus were immobilized by plaster splint for 7 days after operation and before passive movement. All of the cases were followed up for 1 to 4 years before clinical evaluation in symptoms, signs and radiological findings. Results The general satisfactory rate was 86.1%, in which the function was excellent in 22 knees and good in 9 knees. Conclusion The periosteal autograft is a good choice for repairing cartilage defect due to osteoarthritis, with a satisfactory outcomein the short term.
Objective To investigate the feasibility of cartilaginous implantscontaining bone marrow stromal cells(MSCs) derived from chondrocytes in biological resurfacing procedures for repairing articular cartilage defect. Methods MSCs derived from chondrocytes were obtained with high initial cell density subculture. An implant was constructed by dispersing the chondrocytes in a acid soluble type Ⅰ collagen gel(5×106cells/ml, final cell concentration). A fullthickness defect 3 mm×5 mm was created in the trochlear groove of femur in 36 rabbits. A piece of cotton soaked in 0.5% trypsin was laid into the defect for 5 minutes, then the defect was filled with MSC/collagen gel implant on one side(n=36), filledwith a plain collagen gel on the other side(n=18),and left empty as controls on the other side(n=18). The animals were sacrificed at 4, 8, 12, 24, 32,and 48 weeks. The repaired tissue was examined and evaluated with Pineda gradingscale. Results In MSCs group, the implanted cells resembled well differentiated chondrocytes and were surrounded by metachromatic matrix and the reparative tissue resembled hyaline cartilage after 4 weeks; bone was formed at the base of the defects, the thickness of new cartilage was larger than tht of normal one after 8 weeks; the thickness was reduced proximally, approximating to that of normal cartilage, and chondrocyte columns was formed and subchondral bone and tidemark reappeared after 12 weeks; the thickness of the new tissue was about 55% of the normal tissue, with smooth surface and there were hypertrophic chondrocytes near the tidemark after 24 weeks; no hypertrophic chondrocytes were observed, indicating cessation of endochondral ossification after 32 weeks; the tissue architecture was the same as that at 32 weeks, hyaline-like cartilage persisting, with subchondral bone and tidemark in continuity after 48 weeks. The four layer cell orientation was not as clear as that of normal cartilage. The defects were partially filled with fibrous tissue in controls. At 32 weeks, erosive cartilage, naked subchondralbone and proliferative synovial membrane indicated the presence of osteoarthrosis. There were no statistical difference according to Pineda tissue scales in the specimens from the MSCs group between 24, 32, and 48 weeks, but there was significant difference between 4 weeks and 24, 32 and 48 weeks (Plt;0.05). The joint function recovered after 2 weeks in MSCs group, while it deteriorated progressively incontrols. Conclusion MSCs derived from chondrocytes improve repair of largefullthickness defect in articular cartilage. The reparative hyaline-like cartilage is stable differentiation after 24 weeks, maintains good joint function after 48 weeks.
Objective To explore the effect of tissue engineered cartilage reconstructed by using sodium alginate hydrogel and SIS complex as scaffold material and chondrocyte as seed cell on the repair of full-thickness articular cartilage defects. Methods SIS was prepared by custom-made machine and detergent-enzyme treatment. Full-thickness articularcartilage of loading surface of the humeral head and the femoral condyle obtained from 8 New Zealand white rabbits (2-3weeks old) was used to culture chondrocytes in vitro. Rabbit chondrocytes at passage 4 cultured by conventional multipl ication method were diluted by sodium alginate to (5-7) × 107 cells/mL, and then were coated on SIS to prepare chondrocyte-sodium alginate hydrogel-SIS complex. Forty 6-month-old clean grade New Zealand white rabbits weighing 3.0-3.5 kg were randomized into two groups according to different operative methods (n=20 rabbits per group), and full-thickness cartilage defect model of the unilateral knee joint (right or left) was establ ished in every rabbit. In experimental group, the complex was implanted into the defect layer by layer to construct tissue engineered cartilage, and SIS membrane was coated on the surface to fill the defect completely. While in control group, the cartilage defect was filled by sodium alginate hydrogel and was sutured after being coated with SIS membrane without seeding of chondrocyte. General condition of the rabbits after operation was observed. The rabbits in two groups were killed 1, 3, 5, 7, and 9 months after operation, and underwent gross and histology observation. Results Eight rabbits were excluded due to anesthesia death, wound infection and diarrhea death. Sixteen rabbits per group were included in the experiment, and 3, 3, 3, 3, and 4 rabbits from each group were randomly selected and killed 1, 3, 5, 7, and 9 months after operation, respectively. Gross observation and histology Masson trichrome staining: in the experimental group, SIS on the surface of the implant was fused with the host tissue, and the inferface between them disappeared 1 month after operation; part of the implant was chondrified and the interface between the implant and the host tissue was fused 3 months after operation; the implant turned into fibrocartilage 5 months after operation; fiber arrangement of the cartilage in theimplant was close to that of the host tissue 7 months after operation; cartilage fiber in the implant arranged disorderly andactive cell metabol ism and prol iferation were evident 9 months after operation. While in the control group, no repair of thedefect was observed 9 months after operation. No obvious repair was evident in the defects of the control group within 9months after operation. Histomorphometric evaluation demonstrated that the staining intensity per unit area of the reparative tissue in the defect of the experimental group was significant higher than that of the control group at each time point (P lt; 0.05), the chondrification in the experimental group was increased gradually within 3, 5, and 7 months after operation (P lt; 0.05), and it was decreased 9 months after operation comparing with the value at 7 months after operation (P lt; 0.05). Conclusion Constructed by chondrocyte-sodium alginate hydrogel-SIS in complex with surficial suturing of SIS membrane, the tissue engineered cartilage can in-situ repair cartilage defect, promote the regeneration of cartilage tissue, and is in l ine with physiological repair process of articular cartilage.
It is very difficult to repair large articular cartilage defect of the hip. From May 1990 to April 1994, 47 hips in 42 patients of large articuler cartilage defects were repaired by allograft of skull periosteum. Among them, 14 cases, whose femoral heads were grade. IV necrosis, were given deep iliac circumflex artery pedicled iliac bone graft simultaneously. The skull periosteum had been treated by low tempreturel (-40 degrees C) before and kept in Nitrogen (-196 degrees C) till use. During the operation, the skull periosteum was sutured tightly to the femoral head and sticked to the accetabulum by medical ZT glue. Thirty eight hips in 34 patients were followed up for 2-6 years with an average of 3.4 years. According to the hip postoperative criteria of Wu Zhi-kang, 25 cases were excellent, 5 cases very good, 3 cases good and 1 case fair. The mean score increased from 6.4 before operation to 15.8 after operation. The results showed, in compare with autograft of periosteum for biological resurface of large articular defect, this method is free of donor-site morbidity. Skull periosteum allograft was effective for the treatment of large articular cartilage defects in hip.